80
Who Killed Garrett Phillips?(self.UnsolvedMurders)
I watched both parts of “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?”, and I’m wondering if the question has alread...
since 6 years, 5 months ago
6 of 6
Tip Reveddit Real-Time can notify you when your content is removed.
your account history
Tip Check if your account has any removed comments.
view my removed comments you are viewing a single comment's thread.
view all comments
"Ms. Cyrus, the prosecution’s first witness, described one moment in which Mr. Hillary entered her apartment uninvited, although he had a key. “I woke up around midnight and he was standing in my bedroom,” Ms. Cyrus recalled, saying she was angry at the incursion. Still, she said he merely slept there, and left in the morning. She soon asked for, and received, the key."
"TANDY COLLINS...also testified under direct and cross-examination that Hillary, during a dispute over GARRET PHILLIPS, REFUSED to let her leave the house, picked her up and carried her to another room, then set her down.
"During direct examination, TANDY Collins talked about two incidents where she awoke to find Hillary in her apartment uninvited."
Under cross-examination, she said she and the defendant were still intimate on occasion and that he had a key to her apartment she had given him after they broke up.
When talking about a September 2011 incident where she woke up in the night with him in her apartment, Dumas asked Tandy Collins, “Did he ever say to you ‘I need a place to sleep tonight?’” Dumas asked Cyrus.
“No,” Collins replied, adding she knew he was moving at the time.
“He told you ‘I just need a place to sleep, right?’” Dumas said.
“Yes,” according to Collins.
https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/13/nyregion/garrett-phillips-murder-trial-oral-nicholas-hillary.html
https://northcountrynow.com/news/mother-grandmother-murdered-12-year-old-potsdam-boy-take-stand-hillary-trial-0180100
Tandy is an unreliable witness. She's grieving and has been fed a lot of information by the cops, including John Jones. Tandy and Hillary used to live together and they were still intimate for some time. Him showing up to sleep with her isn't all that weird. Her story also could have been twisted after being coached or talking about it with cops and her family, who appear to all be racist.
Tandy is just icing on the cake. She's obviously not racist, and so her gut instinct is worth something. But regardless: 1.) Hilary had motive(Garrett broke up his relationship). 2.) Hilary had athleticism to jump out of window and sprain his ankle...and lie about it,...and lie about his affair to his wife,...sociopath, lack of empathy, control freak. 3.) He had access to keys to the house. 4.) He stalked Garrett on camera and lied about going home. 5.) He lied about eating at 5pm with his daughter (6:30pm) 6.) He was 1 block away from the murder house right after the killing.
Something like forty percent of people have cheated on their partner and lied about it. It is not 'sociopathic' behaviour, it is fairly typical.
Also the injury he had was a scrape, not a sprain. The two are different and mutually exclusive. If he did scrape his ankle escaping, there would have to be blood or skin left behind. Even if the perp had noticed it and tried to clean it up, which seems unlikely due to the urgency of them needing to escape, it is not possible to remove all DNA with a simple wipe. One can concluded whoever escaped out the window did not scrape themselves in the process
Sociopath is my opinion of him,...anyone who believes he's guilty of murder believes he's a sociopath(For the record, I don't think there is enough evidence to prove he murdered Tandy).
As for the 'scrape',...if he was wearing pants or socks, and his ankle scraped into the side of the shed thingy on his way down, there might not be any DNA on the shed thingy. If you've ever gotten a scabby cut like that, you'll recall that there is no blood on your skin for the first few seconds. That's my opinion.
Pretty sure Tandy is still alive.