LOADING: An error occurred. Update Chrome, try Firefox, or visit this post for more details.

⚠️Reddit changed how removals work, which breaks Reveddit's website. Install the extension to track removed content:Add to chromeAdd to firefoxWhat changed?
✖︎
about reveddit
⚙F.A.Q.add-ons
r/
status
copy sharelink
[+] show filters
1167
MedicineWhen a human limb is amputated, how does the circulatory system redirect blood flow?(self.askscience)
submitted 1 decade, 3 years ago by Heimdall2061 to /r/askscience (26.2m)
93 commentsredditother-discussionssubreddit-indexmessage modsop-focus

Given that part of the circuit of circulation has been cut out when one has a limb amputated, how do...

... view full text

since 1 decade, 3 years ago
59 of 59

Tip Reveddit Real-Time can notify you when your content is removed.

your account history
(check your username's removed content. why?)
Tip Check if your account has any removed comments.
view my removed comments
you are viewing a single comment's thread.
view all comments
[–]Funktapus574 points1 decade, 3 years ago* (edited 3 minutes after)

This was asked a few months ago, here's my answer:

Yes, blood vessels reorganize themselves to ensure healthy blood flow to tissues. The process is called vascular remodeling and it begins almost immediately through a variety of mechanisms. Larger scale vessels change their diameter quickly using vasomotor responses, while smaller vessels undergo longer-term diameter changes in response to blood flow rates, oxygen demands, and other biological growth factors. However, there is still a lot we don't know about how blood vessels self-organize and it is a very hot area of research. In addition to wound healing, it has huge implications in tumor research because new cancer drugs can target vessel formation in tumors, essentially cutting off blood flow.

I would also like to add that new blood vessels can sprout off from the remaining vessels through a process known as angiogenesis. These new vessels can fuse back onto existing vessels, creating new network connections.

permalinkhide replies (18)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]ChaosNil155 points1 decade, 3 years ago

I would also like to add that new blood vessels can sprout off from the remaining vessels through a process known as angiogenesis. These new vessels can fuse back onto existing vessels, creating new network connections.

That sounds absolutely amazing. Does the body have a system to have new vessels search for old vessels for attachment or is it a bit more random and more in line with connecting a severed vessel that was just next to the other?

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (2)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Funktapus148 points1 decade, 3 years ago

The sprouting vessels are guided by growth factors. These would typically lead the sprouts into tissues that are low on oxygen. It is there that two sprouts are likely to meet.

There is some evidence that macrophages, which are traditionally considered part of the immune system, actually help tip cells find each other, acting like little shepherds that help bridge the two sprouts.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20404134

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (2)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]garfieldsam3 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Question: what are "growth factors?"

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (2)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Funktapus6 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Growth factors in this context are actually signaling molecules that tissues produce when they run low on oxygen. They create a chemical gradient that vessels like to migrate up.

VEGF is the big one for angiogenesis

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–][deleted]2 points1 decade, 3 years ago* (edited 7 years, 6 months after)
[removed] mod/auto

[removed]

(check your username's removed content. why?)
Restore
(30 users left)
Restore AllHide Unarchived
permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)as-ofmessage mods
[–]kneb2 points1 decade, 3 years ago

While this makes sense, what you describe are factors that affect growth, but "growth factor" has a specific meaning in biology, and so using the words in a more general way will lead to confusion.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–][deleted]1 point1 decade, 3 years ago
[deleted] by user
(check your username's removed content. why?)
parenthide replies (1)as-of
[–][deleted]-12 points1 decade, 3 years ago
[deleted] by user
(check your username's removed content. why?)
parenthide replies (1)as-of
[–][deleted]5 points1 decade, 3 years ago
[removed] mod/auto

[removed]

(check your username's removed content. why?)
Restore
(30 users left)
Restore AllHide Unarchived
permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)as-ofmessage mods
[–][deleted]1 point1 decade, 3 years ago
[removed] mod/auto

[removed]

(check your username's removed content. why?)
Restore
(30 users left)
Restore AllHide Unarchived
permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)as-ofmessage mods
[–][deleted]12 points1 decade, 3 years ago
[removed] mod/auto

[removed]

(check your username's removed content. why?)
Restore
(30 users left)
Restore AllHide Unarchived
permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)as-ofmessage mods
[–][deleted]9 points1 decade, 3 years ago
[removed] mod/auto

[removed]

(check your username's removed content. why?)
Restore
(30 users left)
Restore AllHide Unarchived
permalinkparentcontextas-ofmessage mods
[–]AmeriZombie12 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Even more interesting is that this is one of the key mechanisms for the metastasis of tumors. Once they hijack the process of angiogenesis, they start shunting more blood (thus more nutrients, oxygen, etc) to themselves in order to grow bigger and nastier that much faster.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]ChaosNil5 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Huh, that is interesting. I always assumed that it just sorta took a single cell that started multiplying. I wasn't thinking that it would also impact the other functions around it for that.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]drLagrangian10 points1 decade, 3 years ago

it helps to figure that cancer isn't really a cell that has gone bad, but a process.

the body is full of processes and procedures that make it work automatically. cells are born and die according to these processes and rules, they respond to hormones and factors according to the plan, and so on.

but what if one part of the process goes wrong?

what if the parts of the immune system that attack threats is working fine, but the parts that give or create targets go wrong? that's an autoimmune disease.

The processes that cause swelling to fight infection works right - but the process that decides some random particle is to be ignored or fought doesn't work? that's an allergic reaction.

Cancer is caused first because a part of the cell that keeps watch for mistakes in its own code gets broken. If it can't fix itself (or kill itself for the good of the whole) those mistakes will continue to build up. this happens a lot, but usually doesn't cause a problem.

but if that cell, which is now prone to mistakes, alters the processes that control it's growth, it could grow out of control.

the vascularization process would be working fine, but it's job is to get nutrients to areas that need it, and when it notices a crowded, resource starved ball of tissue, it tries to work on it... not knowing that the tissue is a dangerous cancer.

then if the factors get set right, the cells can start to lose their cohesion and flake off of the cancer and get to the blood stream. everything else is automatic, even as the dangerous cells get pushed around the blood to other parts of the body.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]sayrith18 points1 decade, 3 years ago* (edited 1 day, 15 hours after)

If this happens (re organization of blood vessels), will it be too late to perform a hand or upper forearm transplant?

EDIT: To whoever downvoted me, this is a thing. Google it.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]No_Co16 points1 decade, 3 years ago

This might sound ridiculous, but does this mean that each person's circulatory system could be as unique in its composition and arrangement of blood vessels as the person appears to be on the outside??

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (2)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]ahndrew_26 points1 decade, 3 years ago

It's not ridiculous and is true for the most part. A good example is to look at the veins in people's hands (the back) they're all different and some hand scan technologies actually scan for blood vessels to ID the person.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Nendai12 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Also note the issue that some nurses/doctors have finding veins. They aren't always at the exact same spot, and some are deeper or more superficial.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–][deleted]4 points1 decade, 3 years ago

That's a pretty good comparison. Everything's vaguely in the same place, (similar to how you don't have a nose on the back of your head), but with slight personal differences.

permalinkparentcontextas-of
[–][deleted]8 points1 decade, 3 years ago
[deleted] by user
(check your username's removed content. why?)
parenthide replies (1)as-of
[–]Funktapus14 points1 decade, 3 years ago

I can't honestly speak much about amputations or other extreme pathologies... I don't know much about medicine. Vascular biologists learn a lot from looking at the formation of blood vessels in the retina (which are easy to see even in live organisms).

My field is chemical engineering/tissue engineering, so I actually try to recreate blood vessels from scratch and study how grow and adapt in vitro.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (2)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–][deleted]9 points1 decade, 3 years ago
[deleted] by user
(check your username's removed content. why?)
parenthide replies (1)as-of
[–]Funktapus8 points1 decade, 3 years ago

My pleasure.

Overview of strategies used to grow vascularized tissue

Regrettably cool study that was published by our rival research group.

Interesting review on how blood vessel circuits optimize their diameters

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Grrizzzly1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

I love your title for the second article. And it was a cool study!

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]JonnyPooner2 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Just been awarded a place on a DTC PhD course in Leeds, UK studying tissue engineering. Extremely excited! How has your experience of the field been?

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Funktapus3 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Congratulations! I'm still in my first year, but it has been challenging. My undergrad was in ChemE, so I'm used to modeling distillation columns and chemical reactors on engineering paper. Making the transition to culturing mammalian cells has been wild. Discussions like this where everyone is so excited are what keep me going, though. It really is a beautiful topic.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]anttyk473 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Does anyone know how we evolved such a mechanism?

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (2)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]ChoHag14 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Some of our ancestors got lucky. The rest did more dying.

Edit: Actually the ones who died weren't our ancestors.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Ricktron30301 point1 decade, 3 years ago

They could have reproduced before they died.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]karanj2 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Natural selection.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–][deleted]3 points1 decade, 3 years ago
[removed] mod/auto

[removed]

(check your username's removed content. why?)
Restore
(30 users left)
Restore AllHide Unarchived
permalinkparentcontextas-ofmessage mods
[–]Arknell2 points1 decade, 3 years ago

So the surgeons tending to a cut-off lower arm don't tie the exposed artery and vein ends into a "U-turn"?

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (2)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]i_should_be_studying4 points1 decade, 3 years ago

For an above the knee amputation, many of the vessels can simply be ligated and left at that. The process the body uses is much simpler than neovascularization which seems to be getting upvoted in this thread for some reason.

The resulting pressure from a ligated dead end will increase vascular resistance greater than that of the systemic circulation. since blood is a fluid in a closed system, it loves to take the path of least resistance, and will simply bypass the ligated small arteries. Venous blood are capacitance vessels and can distend a large amount before reaching this point. Same principle applies however. After a while, you'll get thrombus formation in those vessels and you'll essentially have a plug where the blood isn't flowing.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Arknell1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

Thanks, that was very useful and gnaw-worthy info. I also appreciate the fact that you took a break from vital studying to contribute.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]orthopodMedicine | Orthopaedic Surgery3 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Nooooo, that would create a high flow shunt, bypassing the normal resistance of the body.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Arknell1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

What's all this I hear about high flow shunts? I tried Wikiing it but to no avail. Don't I want fast veins for my fast lifestyle? What's the catch?

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–][deleted]2 points1 decade, 3 years ago

How long does it take to make a new vessel? Minutes? Hours? Days? Weeks?

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)as-of
[–]Funktapus1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

Depends on a lot of things, but probably a few days for clear new vessel formation.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]nerak331 point1 decade, 3 years ago

Is there anything that theoretically could be done to enhance this proccess before a limb is amputated?

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]alphanovember1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

You can lick it.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Ricktron30301 point1 decade, 3 years ago

When there is a blood clot why don't blood vessels reorganize around it?

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]FreyjaSunshineMedicine | Anesthesiology1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

They do, it just takes time.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]stetelepta1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

new cancer drugs can target vessel formation in tumors, essentially cutting off blood flow.

Is cutting of blood flow still considered as a successful therapy? No expert here, but thought that it makes tumors more aggressive and stimulates spreading through the body.

Restoring oxygen levels to normal apparently makes them more sensitive to treatment. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-1203600/Injecting-oxygen-cancerous-tumours-improves-chances-recovery.html

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Funktapus2 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Antiangiogenic therapies have a rocky track record. It's a complicated topic, but basically, tumors have WAY too much angiogenesis to begin with. Lowering the angiogenic activity actually makes their vasculature more normal and 'healthy.' The silver lining is that these healthier vascular networks can deliver chemotherapy to the tumors better.

In essence, antiangiogenic therapy has to be used in conjunction with traditional drugs and it's a pretty late-stage treatment.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]RiddumNotImpressed1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

What happens when the vessels on the blood-brain-barrier get blocked?

Say if someone smoked paint or somehow introduced a lot of heavy metals into their bloodstream which would get stopped at the blood brain barrier.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]FreyjaSunshineMedicine | Anesthesiology2 points1 decade, 3 years ago

The blood brain barrier isn't like a sieve, it's a difference in the capillaries in the brain. Big molecules just keep on circulating in the blood stream instead of being able to diffuse out into the extracellular fluid.

If blood vessels in the brain get blocked, as happens with clots or other emboli, the result is a stroke.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]RiddumNotImpressed1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

Oh. I always was under the impression there was some barrier in the carotid arteries.

So the barrier is the capillaries & vessel walls themselves inside the brain? They're structurally different than those in other areas of the body?

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]FreyjaSunshineMedicine | Anesthesiology2 points1 decade, 3 years ago

Correct. The capillaries in the brain have tighter junctions between the cells so that larger molecules are trapped in the blood stream, and just pass on through.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–][deleted]1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

baroreceptors cause vasoconstriction upon rupture of blood vessels in order to bring back to normal blood pressure.

permalinkparentcontextas-of
[–]lucideus1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

Then why doesn't the body begin to do this when there is a build up of cholesterol near the heart? What triggers the angiogenesis? It seems like we have the means within our body to avoid bypass surgery, so I wonder why our bodies don't do that.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]tl091 point1 decade, 3 years ago

How big does a wound need to be before there is evidence of vascular remodeling?

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]aznspartan941 point1 decade, 3 years ago

How long after amputation can you reattach a limb?

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
[–][deleted]1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

What effect does amputation have long term on cardiovascular health? Say if someone was like a quadruple amputee. Would they have to worry about clots as much as someone with legs? Or would their heart weaken since it doesn't have to pump as much blood or pump it as far?

permalinkparentcontextas-of
[–]bordslampa0 points1 decade, 3 years ago

You say it's a hot area. How does one research?

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Funktapus1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

Most of it is medicine related. The biggest application by far is tumor angiogenesis. Doing medical research (MD/PhD program) or biomedical engineering research (PhD) would be a safe bet for that.

There are also a couple of us in peripheral disciplines (chemical engineering) that are getting involved in vascular tissue engineering.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]bordslampa1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

But does all research involve cutting a limb? I'm wondering on behalf of the animals.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–]Funktapus1 point1 decade, 3 years ago

Cutting of limbs is unlikely, as that is a very indirect way of getting information about vessels. More likely, researchers will look at the blood vessels of the retina and how they develop under different conditions.

Conversely, we can now grow blood vessels basically in 'test tubes' and watch them grow without any animal.

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
r/revedditremoved.substack.com
🚨 NEWS 🚨
✖︎

Important: Reddit Changed How Removals Work

A recent Reddit update makes mod-removed content disappear from profile pages, which breaks Reveddit's website.

Install the browser extension to receive removal alerts.

Add to chromeAdd to firefox

What changed?

r/revedditremoved.substack.com