LOADING: An error occurred. Update Chrome, try Firefox, or visit this post for more details.

⚠️Reddit changed how removals work, which breaks Reveddit's website. Install the extension to track removed content:Add to chromeAdd to firefoxWhat changed?
✖︎
about reveddit
⚙F.A.Q.add-ons
r/
status
copy sharelink
[+] show filters
356
Thumbnail
Ask CTIWhy This Sufi Muslim is Demanding 'Internal Accountability' from the Community After Bondi Beach ISIS Attack. Do You Agree?(v.redd.it)
submitted 3 weeks ago by [deleted] to /r/CriticalThinkingIndia (104.6k)
131 commentsredditother-discussionssubreddit-indexmessage modsdomain-index
2 weeks, 6 days ago
—
3 weeks ago
5 of 5

Tip Reveddit Real-Time can notify you when your content is removed.

your account history
(check your username's removed content. why?)
Tip Check if your account has any removed comments.
view my removed comments
you are viewing a single comment's thread.
view all comments
[–]mogger_71 point3 weeks ago

I have read the Qur'an completely with full Translation. I have found nothing promoting terrorism and randomly killing anyone 😆 If there was really something like that then I would mass shoot people too . But here is the plot there is no such thing. So that's why I don't do any killings.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–][deleted]1 point3 weeks ago

Surah 9:29 . Explain it. I know about the context.

Tell me if it's an imperative command or if it has any historical delimiters in the whole chapter?

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)as-of
[–]mogger_71 point2 weeks, 6 days ago

This verse was revealed during a time of conflict between the early Muslim state in Madinah and certain Byzantine-aligned groups. It is not a general command to fight all Jews or Christians everywhere and at all times. It addressed political and military confrontation, not personal belief .People of the Book” Refers mainly to Jews and Christians living under or opposing the Islamic state at that time. Islam recognizes them as recipients of earlier revelation. These are enemies who were fighting against islamic state . But now they have lost so they have to be disarmed so that they can no longer pose any threat to country and cause chaos . It's a peace restoration process. And if the do not comply with the request then obviously they will be faught as it is said in the surah .jizyah A tax paid by non-Muslim citizens of an Islamic state In return, they: Were protected by the state extra sequrity from forgien attacks . It's like having a personal bodyguard. Were exempt from military service so no tension in the times of war they don't have to die in war . Muslims soldier will take care of it and they can chill in there homes . Could practice their religion freely there is separate department for non muslim where they have direct contact with the main caliphate where they can share there problems and it will be addressed by the Amir himself. Being a non muslim in a islamic state is such a privilege . But being a Muslim is a great responsibility too . And jiziyah is just 1.5-2% of income . It isn't that bad comon bro people pay 20-30% tax in mordern age . And muslim pay zakat it's a same thing but different name . They both spend .

Muslims instead paid zakat and served in defense.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)author-focusas-ofpreserve
[–][deleted]1 point2 weeks, 6 days ago

The Qur'an doesn't mention all of this. Why do you want to go outside the Qur'an to explain? Show evidence from any of the hadith, classical tafsir or from Quran that it's not a perpetual imperative command.

permalinkparentcontexthide replies (1)as-of
[–]mogger_71 point2 weeks, 6 days ago

Just google it bro 🤦‍♀️ or buy a context + translation book .

https://preview.redd.it/a3x6u538fx7g1.jpeg?width=1088&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=962e5f97cd116856afe07009633f09c24ab364fd

Like this . Where they translate and also give the whole context about the verse .

permalinkparentcontextauthor-focusas-ofpreserve
r/revedditremoved.substack.com
🚨 NEWS 🚨
✖︎

Important: Reddit Changed How Removals Work

A recent Reddit update makes mod-removed content disappear from profile pages, which breaks Reveddit's website.

Install the browser extension to receive removal alerts.

Add to chromeAdd to firefox

What changed?

r/revedditremoved.substack.com